TY - JOUR
T1 - 'It's Not Just about a Rainbow Lanyard'
T2 - How Structural Cisnormativity Undermines the Enactment of Anti-Discrimination Legislation in the Welsh Homelessness Service
AU - England, Edith
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press.
PY - 2022/3/30
Y1 - 2022/3/30
N2 - Trans people - those whose gender identity does not match that assigned to them at birth - are at considerably elevated risk of homelessness, reflecting their marginalized legal, bureaucratic and socio-economic status 2. Recent substantial international expansion to the medico-legal rights afforded them operates in tension with cisnormative welfare structures. Based upon a Critical Discourse Analysis of interviews with 35 trans people with experience of homeless in Wales, UK, alongside 12 workers in the system, I argue that anti-discrimination legislation is insufficient in its current form to prevent discrimination against trans people. I suggest that, without addressing deeper structural cisnormativity, service provision for trans people experiencing homelessness and other forms of social marginalisation will remain inadequate. This argument rests upon the following findings. (1) Failing to consider exclusion at a structural level leads to system-gaps and misunderstandings, producing poor service experiences. (2) The specific needs of trans applicants are under considered in system planning, reducing scope for meaningful homelessness interventions. (3) An equalities approach can produce a reductive and potentially pathologizing focus upon trans identity, diverting from specific individual needs. I conclude that provision of inclusive services necessitates consideration of the impact of deep cisnormative assumptions in service design and delivery, and their resultant exclusion of trans people.
AB - Trans people - those whose gender identity does not match that assigned to them at birth - are at considerably elevated risk of homelessness, reflecting their marginalized legal, bureaucratic and socio-economic status 2. Recent substantial international expansion to the medico-legal rights afforded them operates in tension with cisnormative welfare structures. Based upon a Critical Discourse Analysis of interviews with 35 trans people with experience of homeless in Wales, UK, alongside 12 workers in the system, I argue that anti-discrimination legislation is insufficient in its current form to prevent discrimination against trans people. I suggest that, without addressing deeper structural cisnormativity, service provision for trans people experiencing homelessness and other forms of social marginalisation will remain inadequate. This argument rests upon the following findings. (1) Failing to consider exclusion at a structural level leads to system-gaps and misunderstandings, producing poor service experiences. (2) The specific needs of trans applicants are under considered in system planning, reducing scope for meaningful homelessness interventions. (3) An equalities approach can produce a reductive and potentially pathologizing focus upon trans identity, diverting from specific individual needs. I conclude that provision of inclusive services necessitates consideration of the impact of deep cisnormative assumptions in service design and delivery, and their resultant exclusion of trans people.
KW - cisnormativity
KW - equalities legislation
KW - homelessness
KW - trans
KW - wales
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85128133977&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1017/S0047279422000289
DO - 10.1017/S0047279422000289
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85128133977
SN - 0047-2794
JO - Journal of Social Policy
JF - Journal of Social Policy
ER -